Ian, I am puzzled, perhaps you could explain how these fun processes add to our knowledge of Black and White photography. In a way,, and the same applies to pin-hole photography, it is going backwards. Yes, the results are interesting and do have merit but how do they help me and others like me who are digitally bound, to improve our processing methods and technique?
Norman
Norman this is not aimed directly at you though I have tried to give an understanding why we do what we do.
Would you say in this day and age that reading a paper book or riding a bike or lighting a coal fire is going backwards?, you are right about it being fun however it’s all serious stuff with hours of practice not only in taking also in technique of development, this applies also to pinhole, or any other analogue photographic process
How does it help others, well I think a good start would be to ask questions about the process, how do we meter, how do we compose, how do we adjust film and paper speeds to suit and deal with reciprocity, one must remember that film is not dead, digital capture is a choice, but not the only one.
I edit my film pictures in much the same way I always did and do, Ian will do the same with scanned paper negatives, so my question is how it does differ to Digital capture, you still have to edit the file as we do. if one has such a desire to be creative then the easy way is not always the best, if you like what you see then it’s not beyond most people’s skill level to do the same, it’s all about how deep your interest and willingness to learn and to go another direction and pull yourself from the easy convenience of modern digital cameras, (not that there is anything wrong with that).
My pinholes and Ian’s paper negatives are just another way of creating a picture, being creative, no difference to editing any digital file, the only difference is the process to get there, and at the end of the day hopefully inspire others to try it, and after all it’s all black and white photography.