Winter Feed

Tommy

Well-Known Member
Registered
f5.6 @ 1/100 sec ISO 160
Martin has me thinking about toning so I have given it a try... I will soon know if it works or not.
 

Attachments

  • _DSC0398-a.jpg
    _DSC0398-a.jpg
    906 KB · Views: 31
The toning looks fine to me, Tommy. It's the composition I have trouble with. My eye keeps getting drawn to the tree on the right and the patch of grass on the bottom when instead I'd rather be looking at the beautiful vista and distance hills on the top (great depth by the way). It would have been better to shoot this one from a different angle, perhaps standing beside the tree looking out to the distance.
 
I think Tommy is taking us beyond the tree, down the track to the feed, nothing to do with what's beyond , tree anchors the top of the image and the foreground grass anchor's the bottom left, the path to the bottom right leads to the gate, think I have read that right Tommy;-)
 
I think Tommy is taking us beyond the tree, down the track to the feed, nothing to do with what's beyond , tree anchors the top of the image and the foreground grass anchor's the bottom left, the path to the bottom right leads to the gate, think I have read that right Tommy;-)

Martin I could not have explained it better myself. Thanks:)
 
I think Tommy is taking us beyond the tree, down the track to the feed, nothing to do with what's beyond , tree anchors the top of the image and the foreground grass anchor's the bottom left, the path to the bottom right leads to the gate, think I have read that right Tommy;-)

I think he's trying to, Martin, unsuccessfully though.
 
I think he's trying to, Martin, unsuccessfully though.

Steven, I understand where you are coming from. If, as you suggest, I took the photo standing beside the tree I would have then lost the impact of the path to the feeder and even lost the feeder as the ground rises quite steeply from the gate. Just above those distant hills is the skyline, yes it would have been nice to have more of those rolling hills, and I did have to crop off the sky completely as it was just bland.
 
This discussion has helped me get my own thoughts clearer.

It doesn't quite work for me and I couldn't work out why it was called winter feed.

If the winter feed is the focus of the image then,for me, it needs to be in a stronger position in the frame and not on the edge. Also it is a bit small.

Additionally, because the viewpoint is looking downhill I follow the track down the hill, past the winter feed and out of the frame.

For me it becomes a stronger image if it is cropped just above the hedge:)
 
I really love the depth in this image, but I do think some of the key elements have been marginalised by the crop.
 
Thanks for all the comments, they are very much appreciated.
I have included the original photo for comparison.
_DSC0398-orig.jpg
 
I find the perspective of this image very confusing Tommy. :( My eye line is on a level with the top of the feeder with distant ground beyond therefore I logically interpret this scene as being on a very steep downward slope (with an even steeper dip in the middle) which then falls away beyond the far hedge and exposes what I perceive to be the valley bottom, mainly because I can't see a skyline. Now, if there was a small strip of sky, albeit bland, at the top of the frame then the whole perspective tips upward and the valley bottom become the distant hills to which Tommy alludes. I quite like the journey through the image but for me it unfortunately it stops at the far hedge, even though I would like to go onward through what appears to be a gap, as there isn't enough interest beyond to draw me further. So for me, a small strip of skyline and some toning/detail in the far hills would make a world of a difference. Other than these small niggles the rest of the image has tone, texture and detail aplenty and makes for a cracking shot nonetheless. :)
 
Oops, you posted the, ahem, colour shot ( :eek: ) whilst I was composing Tommy and it's nice to see it and as I suspected, the addition of a bit of sky and detail in the hills will make a big difference - for me anyway ;)
 
Back
Top