I agree with the comments about the mud. My thoughts are driven by my love of the darkroom, so forgive me, but playing with the different areas in PS is a complication whereas dodging and masking under the enlarger allows for the printer's skill to achieve control more intuitively than the computer can. For me the do/undo capabilities of computer editing is too much of a temptation compared with the preparation and effort that the thought of scrapping a print would make. That being said I appreciate PS as a tool.
But still a fascinating subject which rewards study of its detail.